Knox County Commissioner Drenda Keesee Credit: Cheryl Splain

MOUNT VERNON — A local pastor delivered a petition with nearly 3,000 signatures Thursday urging county Knox County Commissioner Drenda Keesee to resign after her son’s rape conviction.

Central Christian Pastor Andrew Beatty joined others calling for Keesee’s resignation after Common Pleas Judge Richard Wetzel found her son, Gary Thomas “Tom” Keesee Jr., guilty Nov. 6 on 27 counts, including rape and sexual abuse.

Beatty cited Keesee’s comment that the community deserves people who stand up for what is right regardless of personal trials, and asked whether she would do the same.

“Ironically, you’ve asked parents and communities to act urgently to protect children,” he said. “I believe the standard is the standard. It must be reapplied consistently, even when it’s uncomfortable for you.”

Beatty acknowledged the issue has many layers and said the petition does not erase the 23,077 votes Keesee received in 2024.

“You were put into this position in large part because of your faith and the trust that came with that. This doesn’t claim to be a recall. This is just a current expression of concern following the trial that took place,” he told Keesee.

“What I think the trial did is raise a serious question about what you knew, when you knew it, and major concerns about how was handled,” the pastor said.

Beatty does not claim Keesee is or will be found guilty of anything.

“My concern is the public trust needed to serve,” he said, adding public trust is not something that elected officials hold permanently.

Beatty asked Keesee to set aside pride and personal considerations and ask what is best for the county and her fellow commissioners. 

“Resigning would not be an admission of guilt,” he said. “It would be an acknowledgment that the public confidence in your leadership has been seriously damaged.”

Keesee planned ‘prayerful consideration’

When fellow commissioners Barry Lester and Bill Pursel asked Keesee to resign on Nov. 14, Keesee said she would give it “prayerful consideration.”

Referencing that comment, Beatty said he believes God has spoken through Micah 68.

“So I just respectfully ask you to resign,” he told Keesee.

Beatty acknowledged the petition has no legal authority and some signatures were from out of state. However, he said it reflects what Knox County is becoming known for and that it affects Keesee’s ministry.

Lester told Beatty the petition belongs with the Knox County Republican Party, which called for Keesee’s resignation Nov. 6.

Lester said he and Pursel agree with the party’s request, but they can only acknowledge the petition.

Broken trust is claimed

Jennifer Miller of Jennifur’s Helping Hands Farm survived domestic violence and sexual abuse. She said Thursday she has received multiple calls over the past two weeks relating to the embattled commissioner.

“The constituents of this county are not liking the way that things are going,” she said. “They don’t feel like they’re going to be supported. Seeing her in a position of power that she has is very difficult for Knox County constituents, especially people who are survivors themselves.”

Miller said that, as a survivor, it is difficult to know that someone like Keesee is making decisions. She acknowledged Keesee’s statement that she is a God-fearing woman.

“I get that. So am I. God came to me and told me to start this nonprofit two years ago because I have dealt with how can I help others in this situation,” she said.

“No one wants to be in this club. But here I am, and I’m trying to do good for it. What you are doing is not good,” she told Keesee. “You are throwing salt into the wounds of survivors.”

Miller said Keesee’s faith was one reason voters elected her to office. 

“We believed you. We trusted you. And you broke that. And it is unfair for you to be sitting in that chair,” Miller said.

The commissioners’ lone legislative action Thursday was appointing Lester as their representative to the Knox Health Planning Partnership. Keesee previously represented the commissioners.

KHPP requested the appointment. Several members expressed concerns that the controversy surrounding Keesee might detract from the partnership’s work.

Keesee says she wants to continue to serve

Keesee didn’t respond Thursday about the petitions, other than to thank the pastor. She had said Tuesday she wants to continue serving the community.

“I know I’ve been through a lot of hard things, and I can help people,” she said.

“I’ve done a lot of things already, and I want to do more. I still feel like I have a purpose here. Until I feel that that is lifted or gone, I feel like I’m supposed to keep serving.”

Keesee said she respects the community’s decision that she should resign, but said she got involved to make lives better through the difficulties she has experienced.

“My heart’s to serve. I love my community, and I feel like I’ve made some great contributions. I want to make more,” she said.

“Obviously, I would love for this all to be behind us and not be focused on this but instead on the community and helping the community be what we can be.”

Keesee said she feels called to the commissioner seat; she was not looking for it and responded when the community asked her to run.

“I feel like it is a commission, a calling, so I don’t want to release that until I know in my heart that God told me not to do it any longer,” she said.

“I love the community and hate that it’s going through difficulties, but this is part of life. There are things going on all over. I think we can get stronger and build resilience, and we can encourage people and help people, and that is what my calling is to do.”

Also on Tuesday, lifelong Knox County resident Andrea Perfect asked Keesee how she serves Knox County through her nonprofit ministry on Sharp Road.

Perfect also questioned how the nonprofit spends its money and whether its charity work benefits Knox County.

A Christian ultrarunner who likes coffee and quilting