MOUNT VERNON — A new law makes insurers’ billing mistakes less of a headache for health care providers by streamlining how overpayments are handled.
Ohio Senate Bill 162 took effect Oct. 7. It cuts the time insurance carriers have to recoup overpayments from 24 months to 12.
Ohio SB 162 also doubles the time providers have to appeal, to 60 days from 30, and eliminates the fee to appeal.
“This is a win for health centers,” Knox County Health Commissioner Zach Green said. “Although it does not directly address the ongoing challenges with Medicaid reimbursement rates, it does provide greater financial predictability by limiting the threat of long-term clawbacks from insurers.”
Dexter Ohaeri, public information officer for Knox Public Health, said insurers ask the Knox Community Health Center to repay approximately $20,000 to $30,000 in insurance recoupments.
“Most commonly, these repayment requests occur two to three years after the original claim was paid,” he said.
Ohaeri said the center’s billing team diligently verifies patient eligibility and claim information on the date of service. This helps staff ensure they submit claims accurately.
However, even with these safeguards in place, recoupments still occur.
Ohaeri said managing denials and insurance takebacks is a routine part of medical billing. Lengthy recoupment periods, however, create additional administrative challenges because records become older, staff may have changed and supporting documentation can take longer to retrieve.
“A one-year limit on recoupments would provide greater certainty and allow providers to address billing issues while information is still readily available, reducing unnecessary administrative burden and helping health centers focus more of their resources on patient care,” he said.
The bill does allow insurers to recoup payments past 12 months if the health care provider has committed fraud.
Takebacks are not a new phenomenon
Takeback payments, where an insurance carrier or managed care organization recovers overpayments from health care providers, are not new. Reasons include coding errors, coordination of benefit issues or the patient’s coverage expiring before the service was provided.
However, in April, CareSource, Ohio’s top-ranking managed care provider for Medicaid, said it would recoup payments from behavioral health providers dating to 2024. The Dayton-based managed care company planned to recover the overpayments by cutting current reimbursement.
CareSource said the clawbacks resulted from reimbursing nonphysician providers, such as nurse practitioners and physician assistants, 100% of the Medicaid maximum. The state sets the rate at 85%.
According to a report in Becker’s Behavioral Health, one Ohio practice reported more than 500 recoupment notices for claims from March 2024 through May 2024, totaling nearly $100,000.
CareSource ultimately stopped the takebacks after extensive pushback from providers.
Knox Community Hospital backs one-year limit on recoupment
In June, the Ohio Department of Medicaid notified hospitals it was correcting payments made for inpatient diagnosis-related groups between February 2023 and December 2024. DRGs categorize hospital stays into groups based on a patient’s primary and secondary diagnosis, procedures and other factors.
Each DRG represents patients with similar conditions and treatments. This enables the hospital and insurer to agree to one reimbursement rate for the entire stay instead of billing for each service.
The overpayments stemmed from ODM converting to a new billing process.
Danielle O’Brien, chief financial officer for Knox Community Hospital, said the clawbacks did not affect the patient but did affect the hospital.
“For Knox Community Hospital, these claims resulted in an overpayment of more than $269,000, of which they reduced reimbursement on current claims,” she said in an email.
CEO Bruce White said that overall, hospital officials are glad SB 162 sets the one-year limitation.
“We, as a provider, are limited to how long we can take to submit a bill; anything over a year is deemed untimely and not eligible for reimbursement,” he said. “Yet payors could go back multiple years and claim clawback right.”
Sen. Bill Blessing sponsored SB 162. The Ohio House and Senate both passed the legislation unanimously.
“Reimbursement rates remain a significant challenge, but our team has responded by increasing efficiencies and improving patient throughput as we continue working toward long-term financial sustainability,” health commissioner Green said.
“The health care landscape across the country remains challenging, to say the least, and changes like this provide some much-needed stability for providers working to serve their communities.”
